Screen Print vs Heat Press: What Is the Difference?

In this article, you are going to gain an appreciation of what the difference is between screen print vs heat press. There is an overview regarding each technique in which you’ll grow familiar with the process each method proposes. On top of that, you’ll get to know exactly their strengths and weaknesses for an accurate portrayal. The last section will get to the point by comparing the two processes based on previously discussed topics.

Some might mistakenly assume screen printing and heat press are the same thing. However, that is not true. The difference between screen printing vs heat press is the way in which you apply a transfer to an object. It could be the numbers and team name on a sports jersey, or a picture on a coffee mug. Let’s see which one caters to your needs!

Screen Print – Overview

The most important idea when distinguishing between screen printing vs heat press is that every screen print must begin with an actual screen. Designers make a screen, and then cut it out to produce a stencil. Ink is then spread over the stencil, with the fixed areas blocking the ink from transferring onto the material.

Each step in the screen printing process can only apply a single color. For that reason, screen printing takes longer, since multicolored prints require an application for each color. Once the stencil is cut, the usual process implies one main project followed by other two stages for coloring. Therefore, once you get the hang of it, you’ll find screen print to be more convenient than a heat press.

The screen printing process requires the tools necessary to produce the stencils. You will need ink, plus the applicators to apply the ink to the item. You can iron over a screen print, plus it is easier to produce a light color on a dark background.

Screen Print – Pros and Cons

Pros

Screen printing is perfect for large projects that need around 2 colors

Screen printing produces in bulk. Once you cut a stencil and decide on your color choice, producing items, one right after the other, is easy

Since there isn’t a need for intense heat to adhere the transfer, the array of materials that can be screen printed is a great deal more

When a screen printing press is used, you can produce hundreds of matching items in far less time than using a heat press

Since the ink penetrates the material, screen prints are more durable. Therefore, the transfer will last longer

Cons

This is a multi-step process in order to produce a multicolored final product

Screen printing uses ink, so it can be extremely messy

The process can be time-consuming at the beginning. It will take you some time to create the stencil. Another lengthy stage is the final one, namely the cleanup. There might be ink all over the place if you are not careful enough

Heat Press – Overview

With a heat press, you use a heat press machine to essentially embed something onto a surface. Heat press machines generate intense heat to a plate, usually somewhere between 350 and 500 degrees Fahrenheit, (176 to 260 degrees Celsius).

The heating process takes place between two plates, usually silicone-coated sheets to prevent sticking. Heat transfers through these silicone-coated aluminum plates. Afterward, a pressure is applied and a timer is set.

A heat press usually has a digital LCD, which shows the temperature, a timer, and the pressure reading. Quality heat press machines are equipped with an indicator light and an alarm to let you know when the desired temperature has been attained.

By following the instructions for the type of material, you will know how long to leave your item between the heated plates. Heat press machines are either clamshell or swing-away. Both designs require the two plates to be closed on top of the item receiving the imprinted transfer.

You Might Also Be Interested in: Best Heat Transfer Vinyls

Heat Press – Pros and Cons

Pros

By using specially shaped plates, you can apply a transfer to an assortment of items, such as plates, mugs, hats, handbags, and clothing

With a heat press machine, you can apply an actual photographic image

Multicolored designs take only a single application

The process requires an item of your choosing, a transfer, and a heat press machine. It is not as messy as screen printing

With a heat press, it is simple enough to do one project. Heat up the machine, apply the transfer, and you’re done

Cons

Using a single heat press, each individual item must be pressed

Some caution needs to be taken since the heat elements reach as high as 500° Fahrenheit (260° Celsius)

Each letter, number or image must be cut precisely so unwanted edges do not appear

Screen Print vs Heat Press – Which One Is for You?

Choosing between screen printing vs heat press isn’t too difficult. You need to determine how much color you want in your finished product and how much mess you’re willing to deal with. Depending on the volume you’re trying to produce, screen printing can have advantages for large jobs.

On the other hand, when you want to be more creative with your designs, taking into account the versatility of screen printing vs heat press, the heat press opens up more possibilities. Using a heat press is the only way you can transfer someone’s facial image to the front of a t-shirt or onto the side of a coffee mug. However, you have to work with tedious tasks and high heats to operate this machine. Therefore, the heat press is recommended for creative yet small number of prints.

When you are making your decision between which one is for you, screen printing vs heat press, consider the equipment you need for screen printing vs heat press. There are several tools required to produce a screen print. However, all you need to complete a heat press project are the transfers and a heat press.

Conclusion

If you’re deciding between screen printing vs heat press, research some different products that use both methods. Determine how large your project is, and how diverse you would like your transfer to be. You may also want to determine if this is something you want to do repeatedly.

Once you’ve purchased a heat press machine, you’re in production. Screen printing requires more planning and forethought. What you can do is talk to a professional who specializes in both methods. They can help you answer which technique is better for you, screen printing vs heat press.